Customers say
Customers enjoy the salt water taffy’s wide array of flavors, soft texture, and large quantity for the price. The candy’s color and appearance are appealing, with one customer noting it’s perfect for a boys baptism. While some customers find the taffy fresh and of good quality, others report it being stale and of poor quality. The taffy’s hardness and meltability receive mixed reviews, with some finding it firm while others describe it as hard as a rock and melted together.
Make It Yours – See Your Price On Amazon!
Your Sales Price $21.99 - $19.60
A quick rundown of this product’s key features:
GOURMET SALT WATER TAFFY: Made in Sweet’s own facility, each individually wrapped piece delivers the same delightful taste and chewy texture that’s been loved by candy fans for over seven decades
NOSTALGIC COTTON CANDY FLAVOR: Enjoy Sweet’s soft, whipped taffy with a classic cotton candy taste that has been expertly crafted for over 70 years to bring back sweet memories
CRAFTED FOR QUALITY: Our original Salt Water Taffy is whipped in small batches, not pulled, which allows for a less sticky and softer piece of flavorful taffy. It is also gluten free and kosher
IDEAL FOR ANY OCCASION: Enjoy a delightful treat to add a burst of flavor to any event, whether it’s a holiday celebration, candy buffet, gift-giving, or just plain snacking
BULK TAFFY BAG: Try Sweet’s saltwater taffy in bulk with this 3 lb cotton candy flavored bag. It’s ideal for sharing or ensuring you have plenty of this sweet treat on hand for yourself
Our Top Reviews
Reviewer: CLEVERELLA
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Tasty banana flavor salt water taffy
Review: Arrived quickly and wasn’t melted together like another vendor’s chocolate. Can’t return food due to Amazon’s return policy.
Reviewer: Mari Arrington
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: saltwater taffy
Review: I love salt water taffy. I order this 1-2 times a year. If you love taffy, you will thoroughly enjoy this candy.
Reviewer: Carolyn Copeland
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Taffy review
Review: Amazing! Reminded me of my childhood
Reviewer: Sareen
Rating: 4.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Too many UN POPULAR flavors
Review: Not enough MIXED flavors mostly flavors that no one likes!
Reviewer: Nanette West
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Great Product, Big Hit
Review: Everyone loved this candy, great for weddings.
Reviewer: maxjam98
Rating: 1.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Mystery flavors… probably imposter taffy
Review: Update to earlier review. Bought a bag in Nov 2021 to have on hand for Christmas. The bag is full of mystery flavors. One purple one was licorice flavored. The other purple one was grape, I think. Most of them pretty much tasted all the same. I did find an apple that was actually green. There was absolutely NO correlation of color to flavor that could be relied on. Hardly any cinnamon or peppermint, not that you could tell because the colors were all wrong. Obviously it’s a completely different product than what was ordered previously. Otherwise, the taffy was ok. Pieces were small and soft, but good grief… this is taffy CF in a bag.Have ordered this product a couple of times now. The first time, all was good apart from the fact that there are a LOT of licorice flavor in the bags. Now, I’m not sure what that is all about. I bought these for the office candy bowl and no one… I mean, NO ONE at my place of work likes the licorice flavor and now that it’s come up… The only person I know who does like it, is my mother (I should have sent them to her). Anyway, not sure why the taffy companies insist on putting a heap of these in each bag because we just ended up throwing them out after they sat on the communal food table for about a month with not a single one taken — that’s a feat in a facility with 700 employees and most of them construction workers.But I digress… so the first bag had a handful of licorice flavor, the second bag… we had more of those than any other flavor and so the bag was sadly deflated when we picked them all out and threw them away. The second bag had also seen some hard times. Clearly it had gotten quite hot at some point and some of the candies had basically melted and seeped out of the wrapper which basically resulted in a very sticky mess when I opened the bag. I live in Florida, but the weather here had been mild that week and they weren’t left outside long after delivery… maybe the mail truck? I don’t know, but you might want to rethink if you are having these delivered to a warmer climate.As for the taffy itself. Very good. Soft, tasty with easily recognizable flavors and seemed quite fresh. I would order again, but really would like to see a lot less (or none) licorice flavor.UPDATE: Placed an order again this fall for taffy (Nov 2018). Only one candy had any seepage, but again, in a 3 lb bag, more than 8 oz of taffy were licorice flavored. 🙁 There are 10 flavors and I weighed every one. Licorice was by far the most prevalent flavor with most colors right about 4 oz of each and one with 6 oz. Otherwise, candy was fresh, soft and tasty.
Reviewer: Amazon Customer
Rating: 3.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Disappointing flavor, and texture
Review: I love, buttered popcorn flavor salt water taffy, however, I am not a fan of this brand of taffy. It is far too sweet for the buttered popcorn flavor to me and the texture is a little bit too soft. I was very disappointed.
Reviewer: Susan D. Wiebel
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Delicious
Review: Delicious
Reviewer: Trisha
Rating: 1.0 out of 5 stars
Title:
Review: Disappointed. The Taffy pieces were stuck together in bag and seemed old, texture was very hard.Would not but again
Reviewer: Roxane J. Vezina
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title:
Review: Loved it
Price effective as of Jun 23, 2025 18:00:28 UTC
As an Amazon Associate Dealors may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
