Customers say
Customers enjoy the taffy’s flavor, texture, and freshness. They find it soft, creamy, and melt-in-your-mouth. Many are satisfied with the sugar content. However, some have issues with the quality and stickiness. Opinions vary on the hardness, stickiness, and heat retention.
Make It Yours – See Your Price On Amazon!
Your Sales Price $22.99 - $13.50
A quick rundown of this product’s key features:
Great Tasting Salt Water Taffy
Over 75 Flavors To Choose From!
Distributed/Packaged By Candy Retailer.
Delivered in a Sealed and Resealable Stand Up Pouch With Ingredients, Nutrition, and Expiration Dated Label.
Our Top Reviews
Reviewer: Sandi DeSchane
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Best red licorice taffy!
Review: Best red licorice taffy ever! Fresh, soft , great flavor!
Reviewer: Michellee M Jones
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Really good taffy
Review: This is great taffy. I ordered the grape and it has perfect amount of flavor. The taffy is soft and not grainy
Reviewer: Grandma in Illinois
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Best friend gift
Review: My best friend wanted taffy so I bought these for her. She and her husband love them and 2 other flavors.
Reviewer: Alexandria
Rating: 4.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Delicious
Review: I got the 15 assorted flavors, and for the most part I enjoyed it. There’s only a couple flavors that I really don’t care for in the mix, and those are flavors that I generally don’t like anyway, and I love the rest.The flavor intensity depends on the flavor. I recognized Orange Cream the moment it touched my tongue, but I could not figure out what the Black Licorice flavor was until I looked it up because the flavor was so subtle. I typically despise black licorice so I wasn’t familiar with the taste, but I also didn’t hate the black licorice-flavored taffy because the taste was barely there. Good for me, but maybe not for black licorice lovers. But for most of them, the flavor is definitely there and they taste great.It bothers me that there’s no indication what the flavors are, so here’s a list of the 15 assorted flavors, as best as I could identify them. I’ve also attached a labeled the image.* Watermelon* Banana* Black Licorice* Neapolitan* Green Apple* Caramel Swirl* Peppermint* Raspberry* Cherry* Orange Cream* Grape* Chocolate* Vanilla* Rootbeer Float* Cinnamon
Reviewer: Tori560
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Yummy
Review: I bought these before, they are delicious! But for some reason the last time I bought them when you open it, it has a lot of little pieces that fall all over. But they are really good taste wise
Reviewer: Rachael R.
Rating: 1.0 out of 5 stars
Title: I don’t know if these are supposed to taste like this
Review: I’ve been an addict of salt water taffy ever since I was a kid at Knotts berry farm. Since I don’t live there anymore I get my taffy online. The usual vendor I get them from hasn’t been in stock for a while so I tried this brand out. These taffys are a lot softer than the ones I typically go with, they’re very airy and fluffy. The flavor is very shocking though, they were almost sour and had a very pungent taste, I’m not sure if it’s supposed to taste like that or not but it tasted very very off to me. I usually give the candy I don’t like to my mother-in-law who shares it with her students, but I’m too afraid to even share these cause they taste like they’ve soured, nothing like buttered popcorn. I hear the return policy is abysmal so I just threw these away and consider it a loss. On the bright side, since these tasted so murky and off i’m too afraid to try anything else, so i guess it cured my taffy addiction 😂
Reviewer: Debra Case
Rating: 3.0 out of 5 stars
Title: LACKING FLAVOR…. HIGH PRICE
Review: Disappointed… I usually get these neopolitan salt water taffy from Winco, they were out of that flavor so I gave Amazon a shot. I paid $12.99 for 8 oz and it definitely was NOT WORTH IT !!! THERE SOFT, BUT THE ONLY FLAVOR U TASTE IS CHOCOLATE. I love chocolate, but I want the neopolitan flavor, and did not get it with purchase. At Winco I buy a 2 lbs bag for $8.99 And u get all 3 flavors. 😋 yummy. So if ur really into ur flavors and want quality & quantity this seller falls short. With the Neopolitan. I haven’t even considered any other flavors. Not after the $$ I spent and the disappointment I got. Happy Hungry Hunting ………..
Reviewer: Prescilla Muritok
Rating: 5.0 out of 5 stars
Title: Yummy
Review: Delicious one of the best I’ve tasted
Price effective as of Mar 30, 2025 06:21:56 UTC
As an Amazon Associate Dealors may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
